Fundamentals of Senior Management – Assessment
Portfolio (70%) and Individual Essay (30%): Assessment Slides
Assessment
This module is assessed through a Portfolio weighted 70% and an Individual Essay weighted at 30%. To pass the module you need to pass each component with at least 40% but overall, once your marks have been weighted, you need to have an overall mark of 50% or above to pass.
Example – imagine your Portfolio mark is 63% and your individual essay is 40%, the final mark is 63 × 0.7 + 40 × 0.3 = 44.1 + 12 = 56.1%.
Portfolio
- Use the Portfolio template.
- Start the Portfolio exercises early. Work on the portfolio exercises every week; do not leave them till the last week.
- Each activity must include the full article with the date accessed and web address. Copy and paste the full article in before writing up your evaluation, except Activity 3 (part 2) where you must include a copy of the slides and feedback before writing up the evaluation.
Portfolio Activity 1: Stakeholder Influence (800 words, 35%)
Identify a recent internet example (in the last 2 months) of stakeholder influence on an organisation’s activities. Copy and paste the example into your Portfolio; underneath the example discuss the impact of the stakeholders and how the organisation responded, and in your view how the stakeholders could have been handled more effectively. Your discussion should include module theory, and you should provide in-text references for your examples and theory.
Portfolio Activity 2: Organisational Leadership (800 words, 35%)
Identify a recent internet example (in the last 2 months) of organisational leadership and how this leader has played a role in the performance of the organisation. Copy and paste the example into your Portfolio; underneath the example critically analyse the impact of the leader on the organisation, providing specific examples to justify this impact. In your view explain why they are an effective leader. The discussion should be directly related to module theory. Please ensure that you provide a rationale for why you chose the relevant theory. Note you should provide in-text references for your examples and theory.
Portfolio Activity 3: Ethical Challenges in Doing Business Globally (400 words, 30%)
- You will be assigned a group and will have to present a maximum of three slides to your tutorial group. The topic is: Ethical Challenges in doing business globally. Date to be decided – Week 5.
- Each presentation will be a maximum of 10 minutes. Attend the presentation and take the tutor’s feedback and feedback from the other group; this is what you are expected to reflect on in your Activity 3 exercise.
- Your tutorial group will give you feedback on your presentation, and you will be able to add the slides and their feedback to your portfolio. In your portfolio you can individually reflect on the feedback and consider what you will do going forward in terms of improving your approach to working in a group and presenting your work. You may include references.
Individual Essay (1,500 words, 30%)
Essay question: Identify an organisation and critically analyse its performance. You should discuss the factors that have led to the organisation being a successful one or not.
Your answer should be well structured, proofread, and referenced. It is expected you will look at the organisational functions, link in examples and discuss organisational performance. You should provide in-text references for any examples and theory in your discussion.
Submission of Assessment
- Check AULA for the Turnitin submission dates for the Portfolio and the Individual Essay.
- Please ensure all the work submitted is your own and is well referenced. Avoid sharing laptops or your work with other students.
- Turnitin will identify work previously submitted at another university or by a previous MBA cohort – avoid plagiarism.
Important Notice
The use of AI in any form to create or assist with this assessment is strictly prohibited. This includes, but is not limited to, generative AI tools, text-to-image tools, or any other AI-based methods. Students must not use images in place of text or attempt to manipulate the submission to bypass Turnitin checks. All assessments must be submitted as Word documents (.doc or .docx); PDFs will not be accepted.
Sample Answer (Preview)
The following is a partial sample answer showing the approach, structure and referencing expected for this brief. It covers approximately 25–30% of the full 3,500-word assessment (Portfolio Activities 1–3 and the Individual Essay). Sources are cited in Harvard style.
Portfolio Activity 1: Stakeholder Influence on Thames Water
[Full article pasted here, with date accessed and web address, as required by the portfolio template.]
Impact of the stakeholders
Thames Water, the UK’s largest water and wastewater company, provides a clear example of how stakeholders can reshape an organisation’s activities. Following years of sewage discharges, under-investment and rising debt, the company has faced simultaneous pressure from its regulator Ofwat, the Environment Agency, the UK government, creditors, shareholders, environmental campaigners and its 16 million customers. Freeman’s (1984) stakeholder theory argues that a firm’s survival depends on managing relationships with all groups that can affect or are affected by its objectives, and the Thames Water case shows the consequences when these relationships break down. Shareholders refused to inject further equity without regulatory concessions, creditors negotiated over restructuring terms, and Ofwat imposed record penalties for breaches relating to wastewater performance and dividend payments (Ofwat, 2025). Public and media pressure, amplified by campaign groups, also made the company a focal point for political debate about water privatisation.
Mendelow’s (1991) power–interest matrix helps explain why these stakeholders were so influential. Ofwat and the government hold high power and high interest, as they control price limits, licences and the possibility of special administration. Creditors moved from low to high interest once default risk increased, giving them considerable leverage over the company’s future ownership. Customers have traditionally had low power because they cannot switch supplier, but, as Mitchell, Agle and Wood (1997) suggest, stakeholders gain salience when their claims become urgent and are seen as legitimate; widespread concern about river pollution and bill increases gave customers and campaigners a stronger collective voice through the media and Parliament.
How the organisation responded
Thames Water’s response has been largely reactive. The company appointed new leadership, sought emergency funding from senior creditors, applied for a review of its price determination and published turnaround plans promising increased investment in sewage treatment and leakage reduction. While these actions bought time, they focused mainly on the high-power financial and regulatory stakeholders. Communication with customers and local communities remained defensive, centred on explaining bill increases rather than building trust. Johnson et al. (2020) note that organisations which treat stakeholder management as damage limitation rather than strategic engagement tend to lose legitimacy, and the persistent negative coverage of Thames Water supports this view.
How the stakeholders could have been handled more effectively
A more effective approach would have recognised earlier that “keep satisfied” stakeholders, such as customers and environmental groups, could become “key players” once public concern grew. Thames Water could have published transparent, independently verified data on storm overflows and investment progress, created a customer and community advisory panel, and linked executive bonuses to environmental performance. Engaging investors and the regulator jointly on a realistic long-term recovery plan, rather than through separate and often public negotiations, could also have reduced uncertainty and protected the company’s licence to operate. Overall, the case shows that stakeholder power is dynamic, and senior managers must continually re-map stakeholders rather than treating the analysis as a one-off exercise (Thompson, Martin and Scott, 2022).
Portfolio Activity 2: Satya Nadella and the Performance of Microsoft
[Full article pasted here, with date accessed and web address.]
Rationale for the theory chosen
Transformational leadership theory (Bass, 1985; Bass and Riggio, 2006) has been selected because Nadella’s impact is best explained by his ability to change Microsoft’s culture and strategic direction, rather than by transactional controls such as targets and rewards. The theory’s four components – idealised influence, inspirational motivation, intellectual stimulation and individualised consideration – provide a structured lens to evaluate how a leader influences organisational performance.
Impact of the leader on the organisation
When Nadella became chief executive in 2014, Microsoft was widely seen as having missed the shift to mobile computing and was characterised by internal rivalry between divisions. His first major contribution was inspirational motivation: he reframed the company’s mission as empowering “every person and every organization on the planet to achieve more” and set a clear “mobile-first, cloud-first” direction (Nadella, 2017). This vision was translated into strategic decisions, including heavy investment in the Azure cloud platform, the move of Office to a subscription model and, more recently, the multi-billion-dollar partnership with OpenAI that placed Microsoft at the centre of generative AI. Microsoft’s market capitalisation has risen from around US$300 billion in 2014 to well above US$3 trillion, with cloud services now its largest source of revenue (Microsoft, 2025).
Nadella also demonstrated intellectual stimulation by promoting a “growth mindset” culture, drawing on Dweck’s (2006) work, which encouraged employees to learn from failure and collaborate across product groups. Partnerships with former rivals, such as making Office available on Apple and Android devices and embracing open-source software through the acquisition of GitHub, show a willingness to challenge long-held assumptions. These choices support the argument of Bass and Riggio (2006) that transformational leaders raise follower performance by changing how people think about problems, not only what they are asked to do.
However, a critical analysis must also recognise the limits of attributing performance to one leader. Microsoft benefited from strong existing assets, such as its enterprise customer base and cash reserves, and from favourable market conditions for cloud computing. Nadella’s tenure has also included large-scale redundancies and regulatory scrutiny of the OpenAI partnership, which show that transformational vision must be balanced with attention to employees and external stakeholders…
[End of preview] The remaining sections are included in the full solution, which is available on order. They complete Portfolio Activity 2 (individualised consideration, idealised influence and why Nadella is an effective leader), the Activity 3 reflection on the ethical challenges presentation and feedback, and the 1,500-word Individual Essay critically analysing an organisation’s performance.
References
Bass, B.M. (1985) Leadership and Performance Beyond Expectations. New York: Free Press.
Bass, B.M. and Riggio, R.E. (2006) Transformational Leadership. 2nd edn. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Dweck, C.S. (2006) Mindset: The New Psychology of Success. New York: Random House.
Freeman, R.E. (1984) Strategic Management: A Stakeholder Approach. Boston: Pitman.
Johnson, G., Whittington, R., Scholes, K., Angwin, D. and Regnér, P. (2020) Exploring Strategy: Text and Cases. 12th edn. Harlow: Pearson.
Mendelow, A. (1991) ‘Stakeholder mapping’, Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Information Systems. Cambridge, MA.
Mitchell, R.K., Agle, B.R. and Wood, D.J. (1997) ‘Toward a theory of stakeholder identification and salience: defining the principle of who and what really counts’, Academy of Management Review, 22(4), pp. 853–886.
Microsoft (2025) Annual Report 2025. Redmond, WA: Microsoft Corporation. Available at: https://www.microsoft.com/investor (Accessed: 16 November 2026).
Nadella, S. (2017) Hit Refresh: The Quest to Rediscover Microsoft’s Soul and Imagine a Better Future for Everyone. London: William Collins.
Ofwat (2025) Enforcement: Thames Water. Birmingham: Water Services Regulation Authority. Available at: https://www.ofwat.gov.uk (Accessed: 16 November 2026).
Thompson, J.L., Martin, F. and Scott, J. (2022) Strategic Management: Awareness and Change. 10th edn. Andover: Cengage Learning EMEA.