Sample Answer (Preview)
The following is a partial sample answer showing the approach, structure and referencing expected for this brief. It covers approximately 25–30% of the full 3,000-word coursework (Part 1 Essay and Part 2 Reflection). Sources are listed in OSCOLA style.
Part 1 Essay: Unfair Dismissal and the Qualifying Period under the Employment Rights Act 2025
Introduction and scope
The right not to be unfairly dismissed, contained in section 94 of the Employment Rights Act 1996 (ERA 1996), is the central statutory protection against arbitrary loss of employment in England and Wales. Its effectiveness, however, has long been limited by the two-year qualifying period in section 108, which excludes a large proportion of the workforce from protection. This essay critically evaluates whether the law adequately protects employees against unfair dismissal, focusing on the reforms to the qualifying period introduced by the Employment Rights Act 2025 (ERA 2025). It argues that the reform meaningfully narrows the protection gap, but that its practical impact will be limited by the continued deference of the “range of reasonable responses” test and by the low level of tribunal compensation. The issue matters in the workplace because the threat of dismissal without remedy shapes employees’ willingness to raise concerns, request flexible working or challenge poor treatment.
The legal framework before reform
Under section 98 ERA 1996, a dismissal is fair only if the employer shows a potentially fair reason, such as capability, conduct or redundancy, and the tribunal decides that the employer acted reasonably in treating that reason as sufficient. In conduct cases, British Home Stores Ltd v Burchell requires a genuine belief in guilt, reasonable grounds and a reasonable investigation, while Iceland Frozen Foods Ltd v Jones established that the tribunal must not substitute its own view but ask whether dismissal fell within the band of reasonable responses open to a reasonable employer. Polkey v AE Dayton Services Ltd confirmed the importance of fair procedure, although compensation may be reduced where a fair procedure would have made no difference.
Collins (1992) argues that the band of reasonable responses test sets a low threshold that allows most dismissals to be treated as fair, because it measures the employer’s decision against managerial norms rather than an independent standard of justice, and he later proposed replacing it with a stricter test of proportionality (Collins, 2004). In addition, employees with less than two years’ continuous service have had no general right to claim, except for automatically unfair reasons such as whistleblowing or pregnancy. The qualifying period was increased from one to two years in 2012 with the stated aim of encouraging recruitment, but there is little evidence that it achieved this objective (Adams and Deakin, 2014).
Reform under the Employment Rights Act 2025
The ERA 2025 originally proposed to make unfair dismissal a “day-one” right, balanced by a statutory initial period of employment within which a lighter-touch dismissal procedure would apply. During its passage, the government accepted a compromise reducing the qualifying period to six months instead. It is important to distinguish the status of this change: at the date of writing, the provision has been enacted but its commencement depends on regulations, and the government’s implementation roadmap indicates that it is not expected to come into force before 2027 (Department for Business and Trade, 2025). Its effects must therefore be evaluated as anticipated rather than established outcomes.
The reform is likely to extend protection to a substantial number of employees in their first two years of work, many of whom are younger workers, women returning to work and those in sectors with high turnover. From the employer’s perspective, the six-month threshold preserves a probationary window in which performance and fit can be assessed without full litigation risk, which helps explain why business groups accepted the compromise. However, the change does not alter the substantive test of fairness. If tribunals continue to apply the band of reasonable responses as interpreted in Post Office v Foley, newly protected employees may gain a right to bring a claim without a significantly better chance of success.
Practical limitations and competing perspectives
A further limitation is access to justice. Tribunal fees were abolished following R (UNISON) v Lord Chancellor, but claimants still face lengthy delays, early conciliation requirements and a compensatory award capped at the lower of a statutory maximum or 52 weeks’ pay. For a low-paid employee dismissed after seven months, the realistic award may be small, which reduces both the incentive to claim and the deterrent effect on employers. Employers’ organisations argue that extending protection will increase caution in recruitment and the use of probationary dismissals just before the six-month point, a risk recognised in the government’s own impact assessment. Trade unions, by contrast, contend that the compromise leaves a significant gap compared with the original day-one commitment. Weighing these perspectives suggests that the reform improves the formal reach of the law, but that its effectiveness will depend on whether tribunals apply the fairness test more robustly to short-service employees…
[End of preview] The remaining sections are included in the full solution, which is available on order. They complete the evaluation of the six-month qualifying period (compensation limits, access to tribunals and the interaction with the statutory probation procedure), consider competing employer and worker perspectives, reach a reasoned conclusion, and provide the 500-word Part 2 Reflection on independent learning and correcting errors.
References
Cases
British Home Stores Ltd v Burchell [1980] ICR 303 (EAT)
Iceland Frozen Foods Ltd v Jones [1983] ICR 17 (EAT)
Polkey v AE Dayton Services Ltd [1988] AC 344 (HL)
Post Office v Foley; HSBC Bank plc v Madden [2000] ICR 1283 (CA)
R (UNISON) v Lord Chancellor [2017] UKSC 51, [2020] AC 869
Legislation
Employment Rights Act 1996
Employment Rights Act 2025
Secondary sources
Adams Z and Deakin S, ‘Institutional Solutions to Precariousness and Inequality in Labour Markets’ (2014) 52 British Journal of Industrial Relations 779
Collins H, Justice in Dismissal: The Law of Termination of Employment (Clarendon Press 1992)
Collins H, Nine Proposals for the Reform of the Law on Unfair Dismissal (Institute of Employment Rights 2004)
Department for Business and Trade, Implementing the Employment Rights Act: Roadmap (DBT 2025)